Malaysia’s descent
Malaysia's Descent Into Desultoriness
====================================
Regrettably Malaysia, once considered an ace in Southeast Asia has lost its lovely lustre and now, it appears, even the plot. Malaysia used to be the region's bastion of political stability, had the longest tradition of a most feisty liberal democracy, a good civil service, education and health standards and an important destination of foreign tourists and investors and the biggest draw for unskilled workers from around the region and beyond. It was noted to be an education hub and an evergreen construction colossus. The people were courteous, hospitable and friendly. There was decency in the country and fairly ample adherence to the norms of some reserve and civic mindedness.
Recently from being ASEAN's third largest economy the country has slipped to sixth position falling behind the Philippines, Vietnam and Singapore in the last decade. The Covid-19 pandemic has brought to the fore several fault lines but the main one seems to be a clueless, inept, questionable and loquacious leadership. Then there is the wide disparity between the peninsula and the Borneo region and a discernible disconnect between the long advertised and anticipated advancement towards developed nation status and the actual reality of a pathetic third world economy reeling from nine years of nefariousness. Civil service salaries were revised upwards sharply in that short time span hiking salaries and pensions for new retirees to unsustainable levels.Half the country's annual budget only benefits 1.6 million civil servants and 800000 pensioners. In the current government ministers and deputy ministers account for more than seventy positions.
Even before the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic the country had slipped into erratic spurts of authoritarianism in the mid-1980s, phases of kleptocracy, money politics and laundering, extensive elite corruption, an undemocratic manoeuvre to seize power from a duly elected federal government and a failure to address the fundamental question of national unity and harmony.
UNCONVENTIONAL ROUTE TO PRIME MINISTERSHIP
What seems to have stymied the country further in the most damaging way is the current prime minister's route to that high office. He did not become PM8 through a general election, a referendum or by routine process of succession or acclamation. He manipulated, outmanoeuvred and eased out his predecessor by appealing to the most base instincts of race and religion and imposed this canard to obtain the reluctant acquiescence of the national palace. The flip side of PM8's government was the controversial cooption of an extremist, insular, regressive religious party that would have had no realistic prospect to be in the ruling mainstream in the normal course. In that respect PM8 betrayed the vast majority of his compatriots and allowed a caucus with less than ten percent of parliamentary weightage to assume a dominant presence and profile in his vastly expanded cabinet. It was a distasteful step as that extremist party had championed the introduction of hudud penalties for certain offences which are adequately covered under long existing civil criminal law. PM8's government thus became a highly unpopular and unacceptable one. Given the passivity and and peaceful nature of Malaysians in general this unpopular government has survived for sixteen months. When PM8 assumed office in late February 2020 Malaysia was not in an ideal fit, proper and prosperous state as the country was reeling from almost a decade of kleptocracy. There were other serious challenges owing in part to long standing misguided policies relating to national unity and harmony. Flawed policies overly in favour of a particular religion and region had caused unnecessary dissension and mistrust. The irony is that PM8's predecessor had not prioritised these matters.
This failure to address the overarching question of national unity and balanced development was not generally highlighted in the peninsula where the bulk of the elitist leadership and population lives but in Sabah, 1600km away from the seat of the federal government. It was Shafie Apdal, the then chief minister of Sabah who was belling the cat. He spoke of developing not a particular race, religion or region but the entire nation. His magnanimous inclusive message did not win him that difficult election but that same election contributed significantly to a spike in the country's Covid-19 infectivity rate.
Some sixteen months after the seizure of power by an ostensibly ambitious but anaemic prime minister and six months after the declaration of a state of emergency the country is in a perilous state of lethargy and limbo. Government is in the limelight for the wrong reasons. Apart from widespread depression and disenchantment great distrust has set in about the current government's capabilities and clout. The restrictions and repercussions of the COVID-19 pandemic have caused the closure of thousands of businesses, especially the smallest ones, loss of earnings and employment and the disruption in the lives of millions of households. The closure of schools and educational institutions has translated for most households into a kind of enforced home imprisonment with the attendant mental stress and despair. Claustrophobia has set in from being limited to restricted living spaces. The elephant in the room is COVID-19 which instils fear, frustration and paranoia about a pandemic that could turn out to be endemic. Its capacity to spread easily is also terrorising the people.
With this dismal situation there is understandably great anger and agony about everything and especially about the government. PM8's government seems to be operating from a faraway punitive bully pulpit imposing outrageous fines, penalties and threats.
This is a time when people, especially those on the lowest rungs of the social and economic ladder are cowed and they need much sympathy, support and basic sustenance to live and get by their daily lives. Officials associated with regulatory and enforcement agencies, in isolated instances, seem to relish their show of power and authority. The emphasis does not seem to be on empathising with a broken, cowered and largely silent people. There seems to be so little evidence of compassion and concern for those living in poverty with the barest essentials. While there has belatedly been some effort to provide cash and other financial relief the situation on meeting daily food and shelter requirements remains fraught. It is the publicised punishment for infringements of COVID-19 SOPs that generate the most anxiety.
Ten Grand Fines
Customarily it is the practice in normal times for Malaysians to attend funerals of their family members, friends and relatives. While SOPs must be enforced to control the spread of COVID-19 is there a necessity to impose thousands of ringgit in fines and requirements for attendance at courts in these unnaturally difficult times. By all means notorious defaulters in respect of SOPs and breaches of movement control orders must be taken to task. But is a RM10,000 fine justifiable when most employed Malaysians do not have even that or a comfortable multiple of that in their provident/retirement fund. Recently it was disclosed that 42 percent of the members of the country's principal provident fund had less than RM10,000 in their retirement savings. It is incomprehensible that such a high unearthly fine is being imposed on the most vulnerable and affected segment of society.
But this disconnect and the disproportion between the publicised penalties and the low savings rate of most provident fund contributors provides a clue as to why Malaysia has faltered.
In the late 1940s resource rich Malaya, had a relatively high capacity to earn much needed dollars. Two commodities-rubber and tin had put puny peninsular Malaya on the world map as the largest producer of these commodities. British Malaya was the largest contributor of dollars to the Sterling area. It was Britain's dollar arsenal. The benefits did not accrue to the Malayans but to Britons but life was not that bad. It was obviously a time when as 'a glorified commercial enterprise' Malaya could punch well above its weight. Then we had independence and a quarter century of solid development and progress.
We were an impressive nation with respectable growth rates, a semblance of unity and harmony and the people lived largely in peace and harmony. There is a wide consensus that after the first three prime ministers something snapped in the country.
BIg Power Syndrome
Malaysian leaders began to talk like leaders of an aspiring big or middle power. It would seem after the early 80s Arau, Tebrau and Lubok Antu lost their relevance and the leadership went for exotic expeditions in Africa, Latin America and even Antarctica. Not content with a fairly reproductive 22 million variegated and versatile population we were thinking of 70 million at one stage to make the nation an optimum or ideal one. We built the world's tallest twin towers and a famous tallest flag pole.
We also decided Sabah should have more people first. So while Malaysia's population increased from about 10.5 million in 1970 to 22 million in 2000 that of Sabah increased from 636000 to 2.5 million in the same period. In short we had become the America of Asia setting goals of super developed status, multi media super corridor, world class car manufacturer, aircraft manufacturer and started paying foreign consultants for the soothing stories we wanted them to tell us. Look East was a code word to say we are an aspirant for regional America status and our neighbours will be in thrall to us.. The country's civil service, cabinet and close associates of the leader of the country became compliant and complicit cheerleaders. The press and media echoed the same consensual commendatory and congratulatory tone and top editors who did not convincingly act their part were promptly downsized if not demolished.
In the civil service there were those few of the super elite class who developed an aura about themselves and wielded supreme authority. They had regular sessions with their minions during which they regaled their subordinates with tales of impending glamour and glory. Collegial and congenial two-way conversations gave way to a practice where the imperial head honcho presided over subordinates who surrendered all self respect and became charming courtiers. Protocol, platitudes and pleasantries became the order of business.
The country's leader, probably the world's most travelled, was also receiving a constant stream of foreign heads of government and state. From these visits there was good business from the hiring of well known marques of cars, backup vehicles and the production and flying of flags of foreign countries. These visits, they say, had that tantric textbook spinoff effect! These visits received the full glare of high profile media publicity but often only within the country. Smartly outfitted outriders on fast motorbikes with their sirens going to called attention to the VVIP motorcades which raced through the highways and byways. They became a constant feature of life by the late 1980s and through the 1990s. One prime minister of a small country confessed to the writer that in all his life he had not seen so many flags of his own country! He did not know he was visiting the aspiring America of Asia- acting big, talking big and always bragging about the biggest possibilities and projects in the ASEAN region.
Today the only legacy left for this anaemic PM8 is that kind of habitual ultra-big thinking. A RM10,000 fine is a reminder that Malaysians can pay these fines. It is immaterial whether the parliament sits or not, it is fine for a minister to claim that his compatriots are not afraid of Covid-19, another to say consuming hot water works against Covid-19 and for another minister to build his reputation on the projected possibility of vaccine outreach.
The reality is that living conditions for most people are deteriorating, the people are suffering and there are no signs of a sustained effort at recovery with a concrete plan of coordinated considered action. Where are the people in this top-to-bottom driven country and do they matter.
Numbness about numbers in new Malaysia is well established. Vision 2020 was a good, catchy mesmerising formulation while it lasted. Then the people will either forget or say it is passé.
What this government seems to like doing is to continue providing numbers. There is some inexplicable magic about numbers here. The current concern appears to be one of bringing active total Covid-19 cases to below 4000. This is the latest hot number after 16 months of crunching and conveying numbers by the principal health authority, the coordinating ministers and PM8. This 4000 figure appears to be very important. PM8 mentioned it and it is the latest mantra. Given the distrust and disappointments with PM8 nothing is new. The numbers game will be replayed although it will not attract the resonance that the first five development plans had had. Numbers have moved from the realm of appreciable fact to fiction.
More pertinently and regrettably under the incumbent PM8 the esteem, authority, aura and the powerful pivotal role of the office of the prime minister has been diminished, undermined and rendered almost impotent. He is on murky ground. It is clear that he has put the popular and respected king in a somewhat untenable beleaguered situation. Then there is a suspended parliament, the suspected minority status of the government and an inability to engender popular trust in efforts to counter Covid-19, a contracting economy and an escalating debt burden. These issues create more despair than confidence about the immediate future.
No prime minister of Malaysia can hope to function fully when he or she with a small band of bureaucrats thwarts the palace, the majority of the people and parliament. While constitutional provisions confer enormous power on the prime minister he or she cannot realistically think of holding the King, the people and parliament in abeyance.
It may be timely to pen a valedictory note to PM8.
Santha
June 29, 2021
PS:Please share!!!
Please ignore the rest
PM8, The Shaky , Sly Survivor
Sent from my iPhone
====================================
Regrettably Malaysia, once considered an ace in Southeast Asia has lost its lovely lustre and now, it appears, even the plot. Malaysia used to be the region's bastion of political stability, had the longest tradition of a most feisty liberal democracy, a good civil service, education and health standards and an important destination of foreign tourists and investors and the biggest draw for unskilled workers from around the region and beyond. It was noted to be an education hub and an evergreen construction colossus. The people were courteous, hospitable and friendly. There was decency in the country and fairly ample adherence to the norms of some reserve and civic mindedness.
Recently from being ASEAN's third largest economy the country has slipped to sixth position falling behind the Philippines, Vietnam and Singapore in the last decade. The Covid-19 pandemic has brought to the fore several fault lines but the main one seems to be a clueless, inept, questionable and loquacious leadership. Then there is the wide disparity between the peninsula and the Borneo region and a discernible disconnect between the long advertised and anticipated advancement towards developed nation status and the actual reality of a pathetic third world economy reeling from nine years of nefariousness. Civil service salaries were revised upwards sharply in that short time span hiking salaries and pensions for new retirees to unsustainable levels.Half the country's annual budget only benefits 1.6 million civil servants and 800000 pensioners. In the current government ministers and deputy ministers account for more than seventy positions.
Even before the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic the country had slipped into erratic spurts of authoritarianism in the mid-1980s, phases of kleptocracy, money politics and laundering, extensive elite corruption, an undemocratic manoeuvre to seize power from a duly elected federal government and a failure to address the fundamental question of national unity and harmony.
UNCONVENTIONAL ROUTE TO PRIME MINISTERSHIP
What seems to have stymied the country further in the most damaging way is the current prime minister's route to that high office. He did not become PM8 through a general election, a referendum or by routine process of succession or acclamation. He manipulated, outmanoeuvred and eased out his predecessor by appealing to the most base instincts of race and religion and imposed this canard to obtain the reluctant acquiescence of the national palace. The flip side of PM8's government was the controversial cooption of an extremist, insular, regressive religious party that would have had no realistic prospect to be in the ruling mainstream in the normal course. In that respect PM8 betrayed the vast majority of his compatriots and allowed a caucus with less than ten percent of parliamentary weightage to assume a dominant presence and profile in his vastly expanded cabinet. It was a distasteful step as that extremist party had championed the introduction of hudud penalties for certain offences which are adequately covered under long existing civil criminal law. PM8's government thus became a highly unpopular and unacceptable one. Given the passivity and and peaceful nature of Malaysians in general this unpopular government has survived for sixteen months. When PM8 assumed office in late February 2020 Malaysia was not in an ideal fit, proper and prosperous state as the country was reeling from almost a decade of kleptocracy. There were other serious challenges owing in part to long standing misguided policies relating to national unity and harmony. Flawed policies overly in favour of a particular religion and region had caused unnecessary dissension and mistrust. The irony is that PM8's predecessor had not prioritised these matters.
This failure to address the overarching question of national unity and balanced development was not generally highlighted in the peninsula where the bulk of the elitist leadership and population lives but in Sabah, 1600km away from the seat of the federal government. It was Shafie Apdal, the then chief minister of Sabah who was belling the cat. He spoke of developing not a particular race, religion or region but the entire nation. His magnanimous inclusive message did not win him that difficult election but that same election contributed significantly to a spike in the country's Covid-19 infectivity rate.
Some sixteen months after the seizure of power by an ostensibly ambitious but anaemic prime minister and six months after the declaration of a state of emergency the country is in a perilous state of lethargy and limbo. Government is in the limelight for the wrong reasons. Apart from widespread depression and disenchantment great distrust has set in about the current government's capabilities and clout. The restrictions and repercussions of the COVID-19 pandemic have caused the closure of thousands of businesses, especially the smallest ones, loss of earnings and employment and the disruption in the lives of millions of households. The closure of schools and educational institutions has translated for most households into a kind of enforced home imprisonment with the attendant mental stress and despair. Claustrophobia has set in from being limited to restricted living spaces. The elephant in the room is COVID-19 which instils fear, frustration and paranoia about a pandemic that could turn out to be endemic. Its capacity to spread easily is also terrorising the people.
With this dismal situation there is understandably great anger and agony about everything and especially about the government. PM8's government seems to be operating from a faraway punitive bully pulpit imposing outrageous fines, penalties and threats.
This is a time when people, especially those on the lowest rungs of the social and economic ladder are cowed and they need much sympathy, support and basic sustenance to live and get by their daily lives. Officials associated with regulatory and enforcement agencies, in isolated instances, seem to relish their show of power and authority. The emphasis does not seem to be on empathising with a broken, cowered and largely silent people. There seems to be so little evidence of compassion and concern for those living in poverty with the barest essentials. While there has belatedly been some effort to provide cash and other financial relief the situation on meeting daily food and shelter requirements remains fraught. It is the publicised punishment for infringements of COVID-19 SOPs that generate the most anxiety.
Ten Grand Fines
Customarily it is the practice in normal times for Malaysians to attend funerals of their family members, friends and relatives. While SOPs must be enforced to control the spread of COVID-19 is there a necessity to impose thousands of ringgit in fines and requirements for attendance at courts in these unnaturally difficult times. By all means notorious defaulters in respect of SOPs and breaches of movement control orders must be taken to task. But is a RM10,000 fine justifiable when most employed Malaysians do not have even that or a comfortable multiple of that in their provident/retirement fund. Recently it was disclosed that 42 percent of the members of the country's principal provident fund had less than RM10,000 in their retirement savings. It is incomprehensible that such a high unearthly fine is being imposed on the most vulnerable and affected segment of society.
But this disconnect and the disproportion between the publicised penalties and the low savings rate of most provident fund contributors provides a clue as to why Malaysia has faltered.
In the late 1940s resource rich Malaya, had a relatively high capacity to earn much needed dollars. Two commodities-rubber and tin had put puny peninsular Malaya on the world map as the largest producer of these commodities. British Malaya was the largest contributor of dollars to the Sterling area. It was Britain's dollar arsenal. The benefits did not accrue to the Malayans but to Britons but life was not that bad. It was obviously a time when as 'a glorified commercial enterprise' Malaya could punch well above its weight. Then we had independence and a quarter century of solid development and progress.
We were an impressive nation with respectable growth rates, a semblance of unity and harmony and the people lived largely in peace and harmony. There is a wide consensus that after the first three prime ministers something snapped in the country.
BIg Power Syndrome
Malaysian leaders began to talk like leaders of an aspiring big or middle power. It would seem after the early 80s Arau, Tebrau and Lubok Antu lost their relevance and the leadership went for exotic expeditions in Africa, Latin America and even Antarctica. Not content with a fairly reproductive 22 million variegated and versatile population we were thinking of 70 million at one stage to make the nation an optimum or ideal one. We built the world's tallest twin towers and a famous tallest flag pole.
We also decided Sabah should have more people first. So while Malaysia's population increased from about 10.5 million in 1970 to 22 million in 2000 that of Sabah increased from 636000 to 2.5 million in the same period. In short we had become the America of Asia setting goals of super developed status, multi media super corridor, world class car manufacturer, aircraft manufacturer and started paying foreign consultants for the soothing stories we wanted them to tell us. Look East was a code word to say we are an aspirant for regional America status and our neighbours will be in thrall to us.. The country's civil service, cabinet and close associates of the leader of the country became compliant and complicit cheerleaders. The press and media echoed the same consensual commendatory and congratulatory tone and top editors who did not convincingly act their part were promptly downsized if not demolished.
In the civil service there were those few of the super elite class who developed an aura about themselves and wielded supreme authority. They had regular sessions with their minions during which they regaled their subordinates with tales of impending glamour and glory. Collegial and congenial two-way conversations gave way to a practice where the imperial head honcho presided over subordinates who surrendered all self respect and became charming courtiers. Protocol, platitudes and pleasantries became the order of business.
The country's leader, probably the world's most travelled, was also receiving a constant stream of foreign heads of government and state. From these visits there was good business from the hiring of well known marques of cars, backup vehicles and the production and flying of flags of foreign countries. These visits, they say, had that tantric textbook spinoff effect! These visits received the full glare of high profile media publicity but often only within the country. Smartly outfitted outriders on fast motorbikes with their sirens going to called attention to the VVIP motorcades which raced through the highways and byways. They became a constant feature of life by the late 1980s and through the 1990s. One prime minister of a small country confessed to the writer that in all his life he had not seen so many flags of his own country! He did not know he was visiting the aspiring America of Asia- acting big, talking big and always bragging about the biggest possibilities and projects in the ASEAN region.
Today the only legacy left for this anaemic PM8 is that kind of habitual ultra-big thinking. A RM10,000 fine is a reminder that Malaysians can pay these fines. It is immaterial whether the parliament sits or not, it is fine for a minister to claim that his compatriots are not afraid of Covid-19, another to say consuming hot water works against Covid-19 and for another minister to build his reputation on the projected possibility of vaccine outreach.
The reality is that living conditions for most people are deteriorating, the people are suffering and there are no signs of a sustained effort at recovery with a concrete plan of coordinated considered action. Where are the people in this top-to-bottom driven country and do they matter.
Numbness about numbers in new Malaysia is well established. Vision 2020 was a good, catchy mesmerising formulation while it lasted. Then the people will either forget or say it is passé.
What this government seems to like doing is to continue providing numbers. There is some inexplicable magic about numbers here. The current concern appears to be one of bringing active total Covid-19 cases to below 4000. This is the latest hot number after 16 months of crunching and conveying numbers by the principal health authority, the coordinating ministers and PM8. This 4000 figure appears to be very important. PM8 mentioned it and it is the latest mantra. Given the distrust and disappointments with PM8 nothing is new. The numbers game will be replayed although it will not attract the resonance that the first five development plans had had. Numbers have moved from the realm of appreciable fact to fiction.
More pertinently and regrettably under the incumbent PM8 the esteem, authority, aura and the powerful pivotal role of the office of the prime minister has been diminished, undermined and rendered almost impotent. He is on murky ground. It is clear that he has put the popular and respected king in a somewhat untenable beleaguered situation. Then there is a suspended parliament, the suspected minority status of the government and an inability to engender popular trust in efforts to counter Covid-19, a contracting economy and an escalating debt burden. These issues create more despair than confidence about the immediate future.
No prime minister of Malaysia can hope to function fully when he or she with a small band of bureaucrats thwarts the palace, the majority of the people and parliament. While constitutional provisions confer enormous power on the prime minister he or she cannot realistically think of holding the King, the people and parliament in abeyance.
It may be timely to pen a valedictory note to PM8.
Santha
June 29, 2021
PS:Please share!!!
Please ignore the rest
PM8, The Shaky , Sly Survivor
Sent from my iPhone
Comments
Post a Comment