Stop dividing us further
Stop Dividing Us Further
The state elections which saw so much race and religious rhetorics played out, was perceived as one of the most toxic election in the history of Malaysia. Thankfully, it has concluded with state governments formed in Kedah, Kelantan, Terengganu and Penang with Selangor and Negri Sembilan to follow soon.
Ironically, the race and religious rhetorics has taken another twist with Penang seeing an intra-race confusion for the Deputy Chief Minister (DCM) II post, who is theoretically supposed to represent the interest of Malaysians from the Indian community.
3-term assemblyman, YB Tuan Jagdeep Singh Deo has just taken oath as a state executive councillor and also DCM II when the outgoing DCM II Prof Dr Ramasamy burst into the scene with more racial rhetorics, or more accurately, intra-racial rhetorics.
Prof Ramasamy said that the DCM II post, which was created in 2008 in the aftermath of the Hindraf rally, was reserved for Malaysians of Indian Tamil origins.
There is definitely a course correction that needs to be done here. Historically since 2008, the DCM II post was reserved for a Malaysian of Indian origins. Prof Dr Ramasamy, a Tamil, has held it for 3 terms and has the distinction of being the first and so far only Malaysian Indian DCM.
Here comes the explanation. It is a post reserved for Malaysian Indians, not exclusively Malaysian Indian of Tamil ethnicity. Thus, in this context, YB Tuan Jagdeep, being of Malaysian Indian of Punjabi descent, is as Malaysian Indian as much as Prof Dr Ramasamy is a Malaysian Indian.
Last I checked, both Tamil Nadu and Punjab are not parts of the African and European continent but part of India which just celebrated its 75th Independence Day. Thus any Tamil, Punjabi, Malayalee, Gujerati, Telugu,Marathi, Assamese, Bihari or Kahmiri are Indians.
By extension all those who trace their roots to India are Indian origin. So YB Jagdeep is as Indian as Prof Dr Ramasamy. Granted, the Tamil community is the majority amongst the Indians in Malaysia but there are so many Malayalee, Telugus, Punjabis and Gujeratis too.
I'm of the opinion that we must undertake the multiplier effect rather than a divider effect on our community and country.
Firstly,we are all Malaysians regardless of where our ancestors came from ie. Indonesia, China, India, Persia, Phillipines, Bangladesh, Arabs etc.
Secondly, for the minority Indian origin Malaysians, irrespective of origin from which state of India, we are all of Indian descent.
So please stop this divisive attitude.
It's too narrow. It's too shallow. Let's move away from this narrow lens that we coin ourselves as.
Every Malaysian Indian who won in this election was voted in by Malays, Chinese, Indians, Bumiputeras, non Bumiputeras, males, females, young and old Malaysians.
If we continue being segmented and inter- or intra-racialistic in our views, we don't have any right to talk about Unity and Hope.
Stop dividing us further!
We are all united.
Do your best for Penang and Malaysia.
As we celebrate our Independace Day this month, let me remind everyone that
a leader of a multiracial and multi-religious party like DAP, should be capable of representing all ethnicities and races.
Help everyone without fear and favour.
Kita semua Anak Malaysia!
Dr Lingesh
Sent from my iPhone
The state elections which saw so much race and religious rhetorics played out, was perceived as one of the most toxic election in the history of Malaysia. Thankfully, it has concluded with state governments formed in Kedah, Kelantan, Terengganu and Penang with Selangor and Negri Sembilan to follow soon.
Ironically, the race and religious rhetorics has taken another twist with Penang seeing an intra-race confusion for the Deputy Chief Minister (DCM) II post, who is theoretically supposed to represent the interest of Malaysians from the Indian community.
3-term assemblyman, YB Tuan Jagdeep Singh Deo has just taken oath as a state executive councillor and also DCM II when the outgoing DCM II Prof Dr Ramasamy burst into the scene with more racial rhetorics, or more accurately, intra-racial rhetorics.
Prof Ramasamy said that the DCM II post, which was created in 2008 in the aftermath of the Hindraf rally, was reserved for Malaysians of Indian Tamil origins.
There is definitely a course correction that needs to be done here. Historically since 2008, the DCM II post was reserved for a Malaysian of Indian origins. Prof Dr Ramasamy, a Tamil, has held it for 3 terms and has the distinction of being the first and so far only Malaysian Indian DCM.
Here comes the explanation. It is a post reserved for Malaysian Indians, not exclusively Malaysian Indian of Tamil ethnicity. Thus, in this context, YB Tuan Jagdeep, being of Malaysian Indian of Punjabi descent, is as Malaysian Indian as much as Prof Dr Ramasamy is a Malaysian Indian.
Last I checked, both Tamil Nadu and Punjab are not parts of the African and European continent but part of India which just celebrated its 75th Independence Day. Thus any Tamil, Punjabi, Malayalee, Gujerati, Telugu,Marathi, Assamese, Bihari or Kahmiri are Indians.
By extension all those who trace their roots to India are Indian origin. So YB Jagdeep is as Indian as Prof Dr Ramasamy. Granted, the Tamil community is the majority amongst the Indians in Malaysia but there are so many Malayalee, Telugus, Punjabis and Gujeratis too.
I'm of the opinion that we must undertake the multiplier effect rather than a divider effect on our community and country.
Firstly,we are all Malaysians regardless of where our ancestors came from ie. Indonesia, China, India, Persia, Phillipines, Bangladesh, Arabs etc.
Secondly, for the minority Indian origin Malaysians, irrespective of origin from which state of India, we are all of Indian descent.
So please stop this divisive attitude.
It's too narrow. It's too shallow. Let's move away from this narrow lens that we coin ourselves as.
Every Malaysian Indian who won in this election was voted in by Malays, Chinese, Indians, Bumiputeras, non Bumiputeras, males, females, young and old Malaysians.
If we continue being segmented and inter- or intra-racialistic in our views, we don't have any right to talk about Unity and Hope.
Stop dividing us further!
We are all united.
Do your best for Penang and Malaysia.
As we celebrate our Independace Day this month, let me remind everyone that
a leader of a multiracial and multi-religious party like DAP, should be capable of representing all ethnicities and races.
Help everyone without fear and favour.
Kita semua Anak Malaysia!
Dr Lingesh
Sent from my iPhone
Comments
Post a Comment