Reinstate ban on Zakir Naik
23 FEBRUARY 2025
REINSTATE BAN ON ZAKIR NAIK - BARU BIAN
I refer to the statement by Nazri Aziz, former Malaysian ambassador to the United States and ex-law minister, supporting the continued enforcement of the Sedition Act as a preventive law, which is necessary for taking action against individuals such as Zakir Naik who make offensive remarks on non-Islamic religions.
Like Nazri Aziz, I am a believer in free speech, but at the same time, freedom of speech must be balanced with the rights of others to practice their faiths without being insulted or belittled by bigoted individuals.
I was extremely disappointed to read the Home Minister's statement that the ban on Zakir Naik from speaking in public is no longer in effect. It is incomprehensible to right-thinking Malaysians that the ban was lifted without any justification and no release of reports of the investigations into the incidents complained about. When the ban was imposed, the police cited serious concerns over national security and racial harmony. What has become of these concerns?
The Global Human Rights Federation has rightly condemned the decision to lift the ban, emphasizing the preacher's history of inflammatory remarks against non-Muslims. Given Malaysia's delicate racial and religious harmony, allowing individuals with a track record of divisive rhetoric to speak freely without oversight could threaten national unity and social cohesion.
There appear to be no repercussions for Zakir Naik over his incendiary remarks on Chinese and Indian Malaysians. I have viewed many of his videos, where he belittles other beliefs publicly. He has never apologised for any of his offensive statements, and I find it hard to accept that he is again allowed to speak publicly. The lifting of the ban leads to the implication that the government finds no wrong in his words and accepts him as a non-controversial leader.
By denigrating other religions, Zakir not only disregards the values of mutual respect and tolerance that are integral to Malaysia's diverse society but also risks sowing division among its people. It is precisely such scenarios that underscore the need for laws like the Sedition Act, which serve as safeguards against speech that has the potential to incite unrest. While upholding free speech is important, it should not come at the expense of national harmony.
Sarawak, known for its long-standing commitment to religious harmony and mutual respect, stands as an example of how a multi-religious society can coexist peacefully. We pride ourself on policies that foster inclusivity and unity, where different religious and ethnic communities live together without fear of discrimination or division. The decision to lift the ban on Zakir Naik contradicts these values, as his past statements have been known to incite discord. Sarawak's stance should serve as a reminder that national policies must align with the principles of harmony and respect that Sarawak has upheld for decades.
It is my understanding that as of August 2019, Sarawak has banned Zakir Naik from entering the state. This ban was implemented during the tenure of the late Chief Minister Adenan Satem and I hope that the Sarawak government ensures that the ban remains in effect.
I urge the federal government to reconsider its decision and reinstate the ban on Zakir Naik. The ban should remain until he apologises and undertakes not to do the same again. National security and harmonious coexistence must never be compromised for political expediency. The peace and stability of Malaysia's social fabric must take precedence over any individual's right to free speech, particularly when such speech has the potential to incite hatred, intolerance, or discord.
-- Baru Bian
State Legislative Assemblyman for Ba' Kelalan, Sarawak
Sent from my iPhone
REINSTATE BAN ON ZAKIR NAIK - BARU BIAN
I refer to the statement by Nazri Aziz, former Malaysian ambassador to the United States and ex-law minister, supporting the continued enforcement of the Sedition Act as a preventive law, which is necessary for taking action against individuals such as Zakir Naik who make offensive remarks on non-Islamic religions.
Like Nazri Aziz, I am a believer in free speech, but at the same time, freedom of speech must be balanced with the rights of others to practice their faiths without being insulted or belittled by bigoted individuals.
I was extremely disappointed to read the Home Minister's statement that the ban on Zakir Naik from speaking in public is no longer in effect. It is incomprehensible to right-thinking Malaysians that the ban was lifted without any justification and no release of reports of the investigations into the incidents complained about. When the ban was imposed, the police cited serious concerns over national security and racial harmony. What has become of these concerns?
The Global Human Rights Federation has rightly condemned the decision to lift the ban, emphasizing the preacher's history of inflammatory remarks against non-Muslims. Given Malaysia's delicate racial and religious harmony, allowing individuals with a track record of divisive rhetoric to speak freely without oversight could threaten national unity and social cohesion.
There appear to be no repercussions for Zakir Naik over his incendiary remarks on Chinese and Indian Malaysians. I have viewed many of his videos, where he belittles other beliefs publicly. He has never apologised for any of his offensive statements, and I find it hard to accept that he is again allowed to speak publicly. The lifting of the ban leads to the implication that the government finds no wrong in his words and accepts him as a non-controversial leader.
By denigrating other religions, Zakir not only disregards the values of mutual respect and tolerance that are integral to Malaysia's diverse society but also risks sowing division among its people. It is precisely such scenarios that underscore the need for laws like the Sedition Act, which serve as safeguards against speech that has the potential to incite unrest. While upholding free speech is important, it should not come at the expense of national harmony.
Sarawak, known for its long-standing commitment to religious harmony and mutual respect, stands as an example of how a multi-religious society can coexist peacefully. We pride ourself on policies that foster inclusivity and unity, where different religious and ethnic communities live together without fear of discrimination or division. The decision to lift the ban on Zakir Naik contradicts these values, as his past statements have been known to incite discord. Sarawak's stance should serve as a reminder that national policies must align with the principles of harmony and respect that Sarawak has upheld for decades.
It is my understanding that as of August 2019, Sarawak has banned Zakir Naik from entering the state. This ban was implemented during the tenure of the late Chief Minister Adenan Satem and I hope that the Sarawak government ensures that the ban remains in effect.
I urge the federal government to reconsider its decision and reinstate the ban on Zakir Naik. The ban should remain until he apologises and undertakes not to do the same again. National security and harmonious coexistence must never be compromised for political expediency. The peace and stability of Malaysia's social fabric must take precedence over any individual's right to free speech, particularly when such speech has the potential to incite hatred, intolerance, or discord.
-- Baru Bian
State Legislative Assemblyman for Ba' Kelalan, Sarawak
Sent from my iPhone
Comments
Post a Comment