GLCs in Malaysia: Why We Have Them — and Why They Keep Failing

https://madeinmalaysia.com.my/glcs-in-malaysia-why-we-have-them-and-why-they-keep-failing/

*GLCs in Malaysia: Why We Have Them — and Why They Keep Failing*

• 
July 6, 2025

Business, Local
Updated: July 2025
Malaysia has more than 30 major Government-Linked Companies (GLCs) — corporations where the government owns a significant stake, directly or via investment arms like Khazanah, EPF, or PNB.
From MAS and Felda to Proton, Tabung Haji, and MARA Corp, GLCs have long shaped Malaysia's economy. But in recent years, headlines have shifted from national pride to public frustration:
"Losses in the billions."
"Politically-appointed board."
"Lavish bonuses despite underperformance."
"Repeated bailouts using taxpayer money."
So… why do we have GLCs? Are they still relevant today? And more importantly — can they be better?

πŸ’‘ What Exactly Is a GLC?
A Government-Linked Company is a business entity where the government holds a controlling stake, typically above 50%, and is involved in key decisions like CEO appointments or major strategies. These companies may operate in critical sectors — energy, utilities, finance, transport, or agriculture.
Examples of Malaysian GLCs:
• Petronas (Oil & Gas)
• Tenaga Nasional (TNB) (Utilities)
• Malaysia Airlines / MAG (Aviation)
• MARA Corp (Entrepreneurship)
• Felda / FGV (Agriculture)
• Telekom Malaysia
• Tabung Haji
• PNB, EPF, Khazanah (as holding/GLIC arms)

πŸ—️ Why Do GLCs Exist in the First Place?
Malaysia's GLCs were born out of nation-building goals:
1. Control over strategic sectors — like energy, transport, and national security
2. Wealth redistribution — especially during the New Economic Policy (NEP) era to boost Bumiputera equity
3. Job creation and regional development
4. Acting as role models for good corporate governance and professional management
On paper, it made sense. In practice — the outcomes are mixed.

πŸ€” Are GLCs Good or Bad?
✅ Pros:
• Some (like Petronas and TNB) are profitable and critical to national infrastructure
• Provide stability in uncertain markets
• Can act as counter-cyclical forces during downturns
• Offer capital and access to sectors where private players may fear to enter
❌ Cons:
• GLCs often crowd out private sector competition
• They can become tools of political patronage — bloated boards, inflated salaries
• Many operate with low efficiency, shielded from market pressures
• Decisions may be made for political, not commercial reasons

πŸ’₯ Why Do So Many GLCs Underperform?
Let's be blunt. The failures are systemic — and the reasons are painfully familiar:
1. Political Interference
Board seats are often given to ex-politicians or party-linked individuals with no relevant experience. Strategic decisions may align with election cycles, not business realities.
2. Weak Governance
Overlapping roles between ministries, holding companies (like Khazanah/PNB), and the GLC itself create blurred lines of authority.
3. Lack of Accountability
Even after colossal losses (MAS, Felda, 1MDB-linked entities), few are held accountable. Losses are often bailed out with public funds.
4. Cronyism & Corruption
Overpriced procurement deals, fake invoices, and "consultancy fees" remain rampant. Allegations often surface during leadership transitions — but few result in prosecution.

πŸ“‰ Notable GLC Controversies in the Past 15 Years
Year GLC Issue
2009–2018 1MDB Global corruption scandal involving billions
2015–2020 Felda/FGV Land mismanagement, embezzlement, overpriced acquisitions
2020 Tabung Haji Financial misstatements, political appointments
2021 MARA Corp Millions paid in bonuses while losing money
2022 Prasarana Mismanagement of LRT breakdowns and opaque contracts
2023 Malaysia Airlines Bailout after bailout with limited reform progress
2024 Pharmaniaga Medicine stockpile wastage, linked to GLC inefficiencies

🧐 Who's Overseeing GLCs — and Is It Working?
In theory, Malaysia's GLCs are monitored by a web of oversight bodies:
• Parliamentary Committees (e.g. PAC – Public Accounts Committee)
• Auditor-General's Reports
• Ministry-linked supervision (e.g., Ministry of Finance Inc, MITI)
• GLICs as shareholders (e.g. EPF, Khazanah, PNB)
• MACC (Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission)
But here's the hard truth:
Despite layers of oversight — mismanagement, bloated spending, and opaque deals still happen.
In many cases, these agencies only respond aftersomething explodes. By then, the money is gone — and the public trust, eroded.

πŸ‘€ Is There More Mismanagement Than Meets the Eye?
Absolutely.
Many issues never reach headlines — especially when they involve losses swept under "investments gone bad," internal reshuffling, or classified reports. Even when red flags are raised:
• Investigations may stall
• Board members quietly resign
• New faces arrive, but the old culture lingers
This creates a revolving door of low consequences, where underperformance is tolerated, and accountability is rare.

⚖️ Is There a Real Check-and-Balance We Can Rely On?
At present, the system leans more reactive than proactive.
• Public access to audited reports is limited
• Appointments to top positions remain opaqueand often political
• Whistleblower protections are weak, discouraging internal reporting
Unless there is legal reform, stronger institutional firewalls, and sustained public pressure, check-and-balance remains fragile at best.

🀷‍♀️ Is This Just a Legacy We Have to Accept?
No — but it often feels like it.
Many Malaysians have grown used to the idea that GLCs are:
• Inefficient by default
• A place for "retired" politicians
• Not really ours to question
But this culture only persists if we stop demanding better.
Better governance isn't impossible — but it requires bold reform, political will, and citizen awareness.
The more we accept dysfunction as "normal," the harder it becomes to fix.

πŸ› ️ How Can Malaysia Do Better?
If GLCs are to continue existing, urgent reforms are needed. Here's what experts recommend:
✅ 1. Appoint Based on Merit — Not Politics
Board members should be chosen through transparent processes based on professional qualifications, not political loyalty.
✅ 2. Clear Performance KPIs
GLCs must publish audited reports, KPIs, and hold executives accountable — just like public companies.
✅ 3. Independent Oversight
Introduce external governance committees, with whistleblower protections and mandatory MACC audits for large procurements.
✅ 4. Strategic Focus Only
GLCs should operate only in strategic sectors. Let private players take over non-essential businesses.
✅ 5. Sunset Clause
Each GLC should undergo a sunset review — if they no longer serve a national need, privatize or shut them down.

✨ Is a Better GLC Model Possible?
Yes — but only with political will, transparency, and public demand for accountability.
Countries like Singapore (Temasek) and Norway (Statkraft) have shown that state-linked enterprises can be world-class — if managed with discipline, meritocracy, and a firewall from politics.
Malaysia can follow suit — but first, we need to be honest about what's broken.

πŸ“’ SME or Consultant? List Your Services Without Red Tape
Malaysia needs better service providers — not just better GLCs.
If you're in finance, logistics, or consulting, list your services on MadeInMalaysia.com.my for free.
✅ 0% fees
✅ Get discovered by local businesses
✅ Takes under 5 minutes
Because good governance starts with transparency and access — not just for GLCs, but for all.

Sent from my iPhone

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Draft: Tears in the Tropics: Chinese Settlers Who Tilled Malaya…

Does peninsular Malaysia belong only to the Malays ?

Thank you Sabah