PAS' PRESENT PERFECT STANCE
*PAS' PRESENT PERFECT STANCE: TAMIL AND MANDARIN IN NATIONAL SCHOOLS*
Press statement by Kua Kia Soong, Former MP and director of SUARAM, 15 Sep 2025
On 10 October 1985, I wrote an article with the same title. It was about an important policy speech by then PAS Vice-President Haji Abdul Hadi Awang who declared that:
"The question of privileges for the Malays will not arise under Islamic law."
It immediately evoked the predictable response from UMNO that PAS was "traitorous to the religion, race and country...selling out the birthright of the Malays". The Prime Minister Dr Mahathir said the Attorney-General would have to determine if the speech was seditious. Even the Home Minister indicated that his Ministry was studying the speech. Not only was the Sedition Act invoked, some quarters maintained that Hadi's speech was tantamount to treason. The only voice of reason emanated from former Prime Minister Tun Hussein Onn who said:
"The Sedition Act should not be invoked too easily just because people express views which do not conform with established views...the authorities should not stretch the provision of the law to make every non-conformist statement seditious or the law itself would fall into disrepute. There is the political aspect which involves the rights of the people to express their views. If it is blatant, one has to be careful in invoking the Act as it involves the freedom of speech."
Without a doubt, PAS' policy statement on equality of all peoples before Allah was a game changer. At a stroke, PAS had undermined the communalist ideology of UMNO which had dominated the Malay community for so long. The contrast with Dr Mahathir's call to UMNO members at the time to "defend their special rights by holding fast to the spirit of nationalism" could not be starker.
Seeing an opportunity to engage with the leaders of such a large Malay-based party and to combat the racist ideology of UMNO, it was not the DAP but the leaders in the Civil Rights Committee (CRC) of the Chinese Associations who initiated a dialogue with the PAS leaders in 1985 on this important issue.
Through the years since then and the vicissitudes of elections, the DAP has played the opportunistic game as it has suited them, through Gagasan Rakyat, Barisan Alternatif and then Pakatan Rakyat when their marriage of convenience with PAS has suited them.
*Another PAS' present perfect stance, 2025*
Now forty years later, PAS has come full circle with another "present perfect stance"!
Two days ago, PAS deputy president Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man proposed that Tamil and Mandarin be introduced as subjects in national schools to help strengthen national unity. He said PAS supported the continued existence of Chinese and Tamil schools, describing language as an important part of cultural identity. The Kubang Kerian MP said language barriers often created suspicion among communities, and learning each other's languages could foster better understanding. He said Bahasa Melayu must also be strengthened as the national language. Tuan Ibrahim further dismissed claims that PAS or Perikatan Nasional would impose Islamic laws on non-Muslims if they were in power, stressing that they respected religious freedom.
Now, what could be more politically correct than that?
This time, it is not UMNO politicians who are jumping up and down and beating their breasts about PAS "selling out their race". Instead of welcoming this level-headed and moderate stance by the PAS deputy president, the DAP has responded by challenging PAS to prove its sincerity by first introducing Mandarin and Tamil classes in its preschool, or Pasti and claiming that Tamil and Mandarin are already available in Malaysian national schools.
*Are Tamil and Mandarin freely available in our national schools?*
In the old days when the DAP was in the opposition, they were super sensitive to issues surrounding mother tongue education in Malaysia, there would be specialists who would know the basic facts about such issues. Now we have DAP politicians who dare to claim that Tamil and mandarin are already available in our national schools.
1) Even POL is a sham:
POL stands for "Pupil's Own Language". It is the official mechanism that requires a national (Malay-medium) school to provide a mother tongue language (Mandarin, Tamil, and where practical indigenous languages) as a taught subject if there is sufficient parental demand at that school. In practice the policy threshold that has most often been applied is 15 pupils requesting the language at a given school.
Teachers may be provided / employed and paid via MOE arrangements, but implementation is highly dependent on local demand, staffing and school management. Implementation has often been uneven; policy exists but encouragement/resourcing has not always been strong. This dismal situation surrounding POL has existed since the 1961 Education Act.
The same POL principle applies in secondary national schools (SMK): if 15 or more pupils / parents at the school request Tamil or Mandarin as a subject, the school is expected to provide it, where practicable. In reality uptake in secondary national schools is much lower than primary because language choices and scheduling are constrained.
2) Are Tamil and Mandarin freely available in national schools apart from POL?
The short answer is NO. They are available only under specific provisions (POL / parental request, or as elective programmes), and otherwise national schools teach in Malay as the default.
Not automatic or universal: The national school (SK/SMK) system is Malay-medium by default. Tamil and Mandarin are not automatically offered to every national school pupil — they are offered where parents/students specifically request and where the school can provide it (POL), or where the school chooses to run elective language classes. The request/threshold rule (commonly 15 pupils) and practical constraints (teacher supply, timetable) mean availability varies widely.
*Tamil and Mandarin languages to broaden skills and cultural understanding*
In recent years there has been renewed discussion about offering additional language options (including Tamil, Mandarin, and ASEAN languages) in national schools to broaden skills and respond to demand. This seems to be what the PAS deputy president is suggesting. This of course raises questions of availability of qualified teachers, teacher training, all of which should be in the Education blueprint.
*Does this government have the political will for multi-culturalism?*
When the "ruling ideology" is on strengthening Malay as the unifying language, Tamil and mandarin are usually treated as secondary; in contrast, if the authorities choose to emphasise multiculturalism or language skills, then we might get to see Tamil and mandarin become languages of choice in the national schools.
Sent from my iPhone
Press statement by Kua Kia Soong, Former MP and director of SUARAM, 15 Sep 2025
On 10 October 1985, I wrote an article with the same title. It was about an important policy speech by then PAS Vice-President Haji Abdul Hadi Awang who declared that:
"The question of privileges for the Malays will not arise under Islamic law."
It immediately evoked the predictable response from UMNO that PAS was "traitorous to the religion, race and country...selling out the birthright of the Malays". The Prime Minister Dr Mahathir said the Attorney-General would have to determine if the speech was seditious. Even the Home Minister indicated that his Ministry was studying the speech. Not only was the Sedition Act invoked, some quarters maintained that Hadi's speech was tantamount to treason. The only voice of reason emanated from former Prime Minister Tun Hussein Onn who said:
"The Sedition Act should not be invoked too easily just because people express views which do not conform with established views...the authorities should not stretch the provision of the law to make every non-conformist statement seditious or the law itself would fall into disrepute. There is the political aspect which involves the rights of the people to express their views. If it is blatant, one has to be careful in invoking the Act as it involves the freedom of speech."
Without a doubt, PAS' policy statement on equality of all peoples before Allah was a game changer. At a stroke, PAS had undermined the communalist ideology of UMNO which had dominated the Malay community for so long. The contrast with Dr Mahathir's call to UMNO members at the time to "defend their special rights by holding fast to the spirit of nationalism" could not be starker.
Seeing an opportunity to engage with the leaders of such a large Malay-based party and to combat the racist ideology of UMNO, it was not the DAP but the leaders in the Civil Rights Committee (CRC) of the Chinese Associations who initiated a dialogue with the PAS leaders in 1985 on this important issue.
Through the years since then and the vicissitudes of elections, the DAP has played the opportunistic game as it has suited them, through Gagasan Rakyat, Barisan Alternatif and then Pakatan Rakyat when their marriage of convenience with PAS has suited them.
*Another PAS' present perfect stance, 2025*
Now forty years later, PAS has come full circle with another "present perfect stance"!
Two days ago, PAS deputy president Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man proposed that Tamil and Mandarin be introduced as subjects in national schools to help strengthen national unity. He said PAS supported the continued existence of Chinese and Tamil schools, describing language as an important part of cultural identity. The Kubang Kerian MP said language barriers often created suspicion among communities, and learning each other's languages could foster better understanding. He said Bahasa Melayu must also be strengthened as the national language. Tuan Ibrahim further dismissed claims that PAS or Perikatan Nasional would impose Islamic laws on non-Muslims if they were in power, stressing that they respected religious freedom.
Now, what could be more politically correct than that?
This time, it is not UMNO politicians who are jumping up and down and beating their breasts about PAS "selling out their race". Instead of welcoming this level-headed and moderate stance by the PAS deputy president, the DAP has responded by challenging PAS to prove its sincerity by first introducing Mandarin and Tamil classes in its preschool, or Pasti and claiming that Tamil and Mandarin are already available in Malaysian national schools.
*Are Tamil and Mandarin freely available in our national schools?*
In the old days when the DAP was in the opposition, they were super sensitive to issues surrounding mother tongue education in Malaysia, there would be specialists who would know the basic facts about such issues. Now we have DAP politicians who dare to claim that Tamil and mandarin are already available in our national schools.
1) Even POL is a sham:
POL stands for "Pupil's Own Language". It is the official mechanism that requires a national (Malay-medium) school to provide a mother tongue language (Mandarin, Tamil, and where practical indigenous languages) as a taught subject if there is sufficient parental demand at that school. In practice the policy threshold that has most often been applied is 15 pupils requesting the language at a given school.
Teachers may be provided / employed and paid via MOE arrangements, but implementation is highly dependent on local demand, staffing and school management. Implementation has often been uneven; policy exists but encouragement/resourcing has not always been strong. This dismal situation surrounding POL has existed since the 1961 Education Act.
The same POL principle applies in secondary national schools (SMK): if 15 or more pupils / parents at the school request Tamil or Mandarin as a subject, the school is expected to provide it, where practicable. In reality uptake in secondary national schools is much lower than primary because language choices and scheduling are constrained.
2) Are Tamil and Mandarin freely available in national schools apart from POL?
The short answer is NO. They are available only under specific provisions (POL / parental request, or as elective programmes), and otherwise national schools teach in Malay as the default.
Not automatic or universal: The national school (SK/SMK) system is Malay-medium by default. Tamil and Mandarin are not automatically offered to every national school pupil — they are offered where parents/students specifically request and where the school can provide it (POL), or where the school chooses to run elective language classes. The request/threshold rule (commonly 15 pupils) and practical constraints (teacher supply, timetable) mean availability varies widely.
*Tamil and Mandarin languages to broaden skills and cultural understanding*
In recent years there has been renewed discussion about offering additional language options (including Tamil, Mandarin, and ASEAN languages) in national schools to broaden skills and respond to demand. This seems to be what the PAS deputy president is suggesting. This of course raises questions of availability of qualified teachers, teacher training, all of which should be in the Education blueprint.
*Does this government have the political will for multi-culturalism?*
When the "ruling ideology" is on strengthening Malay as the unifying language, Tamil and mandarin are usually treated as secondary; in contrast, if the authorities choose to emphasise multiculturalism or language skills, then we might get to see Tamil and mandarin become languages of choice in the national schools.
Sent from my iPhone
Comments
Post a Comment